Why Two People Pay Different Car Insurance Premiums for the Same Car

Two neighbours buy the same car model in the same month. A year later, one pays noticeably more for insurance than the other. It isn’t random. Insurers price each policy based on the risk of a claim and the cost of covering it, and many of those factors are within your control.

How car insurance premiums are calculated

At its core, a premium reflects two things: how likely you are to make a claim, and how expensive that claim could be. Insurers look at the car, the driver, where and how the car is used, and the cover you choose.

9 factors that change your premium

1. Insured value of the car

The higher the car’s insured value (often called the insured declared value, or IDV), the more the insurer may have to pay if it’s stolen or written off, so the premium for own-damage cover rises. Value usually falls each year as the car ages.

2. Type of cover

Third-party cover, which pays for damage you cause to others, is cheaper and often legally required. Comprehensive cover adds protection for your own car and costs more.

3. Add-ons

Extras such as zero depreciation, engine protection, roadside assistance and return-to-invoice cover increase the premium. They can be worth it, especially for new cars, but each one adds cost.

4. No-claim bonus (NCB)

Drivers who don’t make claims usually earn a discount on the own-damage premium that grows with each claim-free year. A single claim can reset it. This is often the biggest reason two identical cars have different premiums.

5. Location

Cities with heavy traffic, more accidents or higher theft rates often have higher premiums than smaller towns.

6. Engine size and fuel type

Cars with larger engines may attract higher third-party premiums. Repair costs also differ by model and fuel type.

7. Driver profile

In many markets, age, driving experience and claim history affect pricing. Younger, newer drivers are often seen as higher risk.

8. Voluntary deductible

Agreeing to pay a larger share of each claim yourself can reduce the premium. Only choose an amount you could comfortably pay.

9. Safety and security features

Approved anti-theft devices and certain safety features may qualify for discounts with some insurers.

Why comparing quotes matters

Insurers weigh these factors differently, so quotes for the same car and driver can vary widely. Comparing at least three quotes with the same cover and add-ons is one of the easiest ways to save.

Before comparing, it helps to understand what drives your number. This guide on how to estimate your car insurance premium walks through the inputs that matter most.

Practical ways to lower your premium

  1. Protect your no-claim bonus. For small damages, compare the repair cost with the NCB you’d lose before claiming.
  2. Choose add-ons carefully. Zero depreciation may make sense for a new car, less so for an older one.
  3. Set a realistic insured value. Too low reduces premium but also reduces your payout.
  4. Renew on time. A lapsed policy can mean losing benefits and extra inspection steps.
  5. Pay annually if possible. Some insurers charge more for instalment plans.
  6. Review every year. Don’t auto-renew without checking other quotes.

Cheapest isn’t always best

A low premium is only good value if the claim process works when you need it. Check:

  • Claim settlement experience and reviews
  • Network garages near you for cashless repairs
  • What’s excluded, such as wear and tear or driving without a valid licence
  • How quickly roadside help arrives

Frequently asked questions

Does car colour affect insurance premiums?

Generally, no. Model, value, location and driver history matter far more.

Can I transfer my no-claim bonus to a new car?

In many cases, yes. The NCB is usually linked to the policyholder rather than the car. Ask your insurer.

Is third-party cover enough?

It meets legal requirements in many places but won’t pay for damage to your own car. For newer or valuable cars, comprehensive cover is usually safer.

Final thoughts

The same car can cost very different amounts to insure because premiums reflect the full picture: the car’s value, your cover choices, where you drive and your claim history. Understand the factors, compare quotes every year and protect your no-claim bonus, and you’ll rarely overpay.

This article provides general information and isn’t insurance advice. Policy terms vary by insurer and country.